Combat

Cleave: what to look for against a swarm

If you already have a MELEE target and are offered Thor 203, Cut Them Down, check that direct route first: it grants 8 Damage and 1 Cleave. For a structure choice, compare the published Cleave options below against what fits your settlement. Skip Wide Swings, which was temporarily disabled, and do not rely on Einherjar’s old Cleave: it changed to 0.

Demo patches 0.77.111d (October 12) and 0.78.27d (October 19). Current values below include the latest Gates of Muspell and Wyvern Nest reductions. These are published options, not tested counter builds or a win-rate ranking. Slash-separated values retain the source’s three values without assigning tier names.

Updated

The Cleave changes to compare

The developers specifically aimed the October 12 changes at late-game Kobold and Einherjar spam. The global Cleave radius parameter increased 1.5 → 2.5, and its damage percentage increased 25% → 50%. The number 2.5 is the published radius parameter; it is not a claim of 2.5 board tiles or a diagram of which enemies will be hit.

Current published Cleave values after 0.78.27d
OptionCurrent CleaveWhat that changes for a pick
Draugr Tombs1Added in the October 12 patch.
Gates of Muspell7/8/9Reduced from 8/9/10 on October 19; compare the whole structure with your plan.
Jotunn Camp3/4/5The October 12 values vary across the three entries.
Wyvern Nest5/6/7Reduced from 6/7/8 on October 19; listed as Wyvern in the October 12 notes.
Hlidskjalf’s Einherjar0Removed on October 12; exclude the old built-in Cleave.
Two routes to a published Cleave option: an offered Thor 203 card needs a MELEE target; a structure choice can be compared among Draugr Tombs, Gates of Muspell, Jotunn Camp and Wyvern. Exclude disabled Wide Swings and Einherjar's removed Cleave.
A choice diagram, not combat footage or a hit-area map. It separates a targeted card from structure options; it does not promise that any option will be offered.
On this page

Choose the route you can actually use

  1. Start with the problem you saw. These changes address armies with many units. One loss to a single durable enemy is not enough to conclude that more Cleave solves your problem.
  2. For a card, match its target. Cut Them Down is Target MELEE, with 8 Damage and 1 Cleave. An army that lacks that target cannot use the card as a general bonus for every unit. See card targets versus god favor.
  3. For a structure, compare the whole addition. Draugr Tombs, Gates of Muspell, Jotunn Camp and Wyvern are explicit candidates in the patch. The largest Cleave entry alone does not establish the best purchase: retain the economy and military balance and the placement conditions your settlement needs.
  4. Keep the next choice conditional. Use the candidates actually available to you; these notes do not provide a guaranteed acquisition order, complete cost table or winning opening.

Old effects to leave out of a current plan

Jotunn is no longer a Stun plan. The October 27 EA patch sets its Stun to 0 and Damage to 12/24/36. Its published Cleave value is a separate parameter. Hlidskjalf now has a maximum of 2 Einherjar. Compare the current EA changes before using an older counter example.

“Take Wide Swings for Cleave.” Thor 004 was disabled for the moment in 0.77.111d while the developers reconsidered Cleave. Its old effect is not an available pick to plan around.

“Einherjar already supplies Cleave.” Hlidskjalf’s Einherjar changed from 1 to 0 Cleave. That does not remove its other roles, but it removes that old reason for selecting it. The Stag guide explains the clan context.

“A Thor card helps every warband in the same way.” Individual cards keep their own targets. Thor 002, Flurry of Blows, now targets MELEE and grants 10 Crit Chance, replacing WARBAND and 0.2 Action Speed; it is a different effect from Cut Them Down.

For other explanations of a loss, return to the combat preparation overview. For the extra chance after your Shields run out, read Last Chance in Ranked and Free Play.

Sources: Official balance patch 0.77.111d (October 12: anti-spam intent, global Cleave parameters, structure changes and Thor 002/004/203) and Hour of the Wolf — 0.78.27d (October 19: Gates of Muspell and Wyvern Nest reductions).